Gardens of the Moon Review

Welcome, my fellow fantasy fans, to the mysterious, intricate, and elaborate universe that is Steven Erikson's "Gardens of the Moon," the first entry in the 10-book series known as Malazan Book of the Fallen.

Published in 1999, this introductory novel takes readers on a journey through a breathtakingly complex world filled with diverse races, rich history, arcane magic, and divine interventions. Now, let's delve into the intricacies of this epic fantasy without further ado. (Please be aware that some spoilers lie ahead, clearly marked for your convenience.)

"Gardens of the Moon" has a vast cast of characters, both mortal and immortal, human and non-human, each with their intricate backstories, motivations, and alliances. Our journey primarily begins in the city of Pale, under the shadow of Moon's Spawn, a floating fortress commanded by the enigmatic Anomander Rake, leader of the non-human Tiste Andii.

Spoiler Alert The Malazan Empire, led by the ambitious and ruthless Empress Laseen, is seeking to expand its territories, and Pale is the most recent city in its path. The book kicks off with an extensive and devastating siege of Pale, after which we are introduced to various key characters, including the survivors from the Malazan forces such as Sergeant Whiskeyjack and his squad of soldiers and mages known as the Bridgeburners.

But the story doesn't merely limit itself to military conquests. The labyrinthine plot weaves together threads of political intrigue, ancient rivalries, and the machinations of gods and ascendants (beings with immense power who have ascended beyond mortality). Central to these plots is the enigmatic Deck of Dragons, a tarot-like system that the characters use to interpret the often inscrutable intentions of gods and ascendants.

Spoiler Alert The narrative later transports us to the grand city of Darujhistan, the Jewel of Genabackis and the next target of the Malazan Empire. It's here that many plot threads intertwine, leading to a climactic convergence. Erikson introduces a host of new characters like Kruppe, a seemingly simple and rotund man but with an intellect that plays a pivotal role in the narrative, and the youthful thief Crokus, chosen by the twin deities of luck.

Erikson's ambitious scope in "Gardens of the Moon" calls for a deep dive into an array of cultures, histories, and mythologies. The novel pushes the boundaries of the fantasy genre with its emphasis on anthropological and archaeological detail, creating a sense of realism and depth rarely seen in the genre.

Despite this, the complexity of "Gardens of the Moon" could be daunting for some. Erikson drops readers into the midst of a high-stakes plot with minimal exposition, demanding attention and patience. The intricate relationships between characters, races, factions, gods, and magic systems are unraveled slowly, much like peeling the layers off an onion.

"Gardens of the Moon" sets the stage for what promises to be an elaborate series that explores themes of power, fate, loyalty, and the blurred lines between good and evil. Its storytelling challenges traditional narrative structures and provides readers with a truly immersive and rewarding experience. This, my fellow fantasy fans, is a journey that promises to be as rewarding as it is demanding. So, get ready to step into a world as vast and intricate as the Deck of Dragons itself. Buckle up, and welcome to the Malazan Book of the Fallen.

Gardens of the Moon Time Investment

"Gardens of the Moon," the first installment in the Malazan Book of the Fallen series, is a robust and detailed epic, comprising around 712 pages in its standard paperback format. This page count is, in itself, a testament to the sprawling world Steven Erikson has created and the complexity of the plot.

For the average reader, tackling a novel of this magnitude might take some time. Depending on your reading speed, it could take approximately 23 to 30 hours to complete the book. For a more casual reader, dedicating about two hours per day, the book would last nearly two weeks. However, those who are used to delving into extensive fantasy epics might find themselves completing the journey in less than a week.

If you're an audiobook enthusiast, "Gardens of the Moon" is available in this format and narrated by Ralph Lister. Lister's immersive narration style brings Erikson's intricate world-building to life, and he skillfully navigates the vast array of characters and races. The audiobook has a length of approximately 26 hours and 8 minutes. This extended timeframe reflects the dense narrative and the narrator's deliberate pace to help listeners comprehend the complexity of the story.

Regardless of whether you choose to read or listen to "Gardens of the Moon," this detailed epic demands a commitment to immerse oneself in its narrative and world. Prepare yourself for a deep dive into one of the most complex fantasy landscapes in modern literature.

Gardens of the Moon Plot Review

The plot of "Gardens of the Moon" is intricately woven, layered with complexities and fraught with twists and turns that keep the reader on edge. The narrative is immersive, revolving around the Malazan Empire's siege of the city of Pale and the subsequent march to Darujhistan, the last of the Free Cities of Genabackis. Erikson intricately navigates numerous character viewpoints, giving the reader an expansive understanding of the Malazan world from various perspectives.

The pace of the plot is not straightforward. Erikson immerses readers in the middle of the action from the start, without any hand-holding. This technique can be confusing initially but proves to be an effective storytelling approach, enhancing the sense of unfolding mystery and grandeur as the story progresses. Subplots are abundant, weaving through the primary storyline and adding depth and richness to the narrative. Although the high number of plots and subplots could seem overwhelming, they are well-handled, each vital piece forming part of the larger, intricate puzzle that is the Malazan world.

One could argue that there are some plot holes or moments of ambiguity, but most are answered in the subsequent books, demonstrating Erikson's masterful control over his narrative. These gaps add to the sense of mystery and intrigue, urging readers to continue the series for answers.

Given the intricacy of its plot, the depth of its subplots, and the ambitious narrative structure, "Gardens of the Moon" deserves a 4.5 out of 5 for plot/story. It might not be an easy read, but it's certainly rewarding for those who relish complex narratives and intricate world-building. This book sets the bar high for the epic fantasy genre, challenging readers to engage deeply with the text.

Gardens of the Moon Character Development Review

The character development in "Gardens of the Moon" is exceptional and stands as one of the major strengths of the novel. Erikson skillfully crafts a cast of complex and multi-faceted characters that are real and intriguing. The protagonist, Sergeant Whiskeyjack and his squad of soldiers, known as the Bridgeburners, are among the most engaging. Each member of the squad is distinctly drawn, with unique quirks, strengths, and weaknesses. Their camaraderie, combined with their individuality, creates an absorbing dynamic that enhances the overall narrative.

Another compelling character is Anomander Rake, the enigmatic and powerful lord of the Tiste Andii, who wields a sword that imprisons souls. His aura of mystery and inherent charisma make him an alluring figure whose every appearance on the page is enthralling. Similarly, characters like Tattersail, a mage of the Second Rank, and Paran, a young noble turned soldier, go through considerable transformation and growth, adding to the depth of their characterization.

However, the novel's ambitious scope means that some characters don't get as much development as they could have, given the shifting viewpoints and multitude of storylines. This can occasionally leave readers wishing for more exploration of certain characters.

In terms of character development, I would rate "Gardens of the Moon" a 4.3 out of 5. The novel excels at creating nuanced, multi-dimensional characters, although some might feel underdeveloped due to the breadth of the narrative. Erikson's ability to imbue his characters with a sense of realism and individuality, despite the fantastical setting, is truly noteworthy. The characters, with their distinctive personalities and arcs, are one of the major reasons this novel, and the series as a whole, has amassed such a dedicated following.

Gardens of the Moon World-building Review

"Gardens of the Moon" sets the stage for an expansive, immersive world that is unrivaled in its complexity and depth. The world-building in the Malazan series is renowned for its detail, scope, and originality. Erikson, a trained anthropologist and archaeologist, meticulously constructs a world that is rich in history, culture, and diversity, effectively immersing the reader into the world of the Malazan Empire.

The Malazan world comprises of an array of civilizations, races, gods, and magic systems. These elements are not laid out in a straightforward exposition; rather, Erikson gradually reveals the intricate layers of this universe, allowing readers to discover and appreciate the depth of his creation as they navigate through the book.

The continent of Genabackis, where most of "Gardens of the Moon" takes place, is deeply described with its unique geography, competing city-states, and the enigmatic floating city of Moon's Spawn. The magic system, based on Warrens, or other dimensions that mages draw power from, is innovative and complex, adding a fascinating layer to the world-building.

However, the sheer magnitude and complexity of Erikson's world can be daunting. The reader is thrown into the midst of events with minimal explanation, and it requires effort and attention to piece together the workings of the Malazan world. The absence of hand-holding can be off-putting to some, yet it’s equally rewarding for those who relish deciphering the richness of the world on their own.

Considering the staggering depth, detail, and originality of the world Erikson has crafted, I would rate the world-building of "Gardens of the Moon" a 4.7 out of 5. Despite the initial steep learning curve, the immersive and intricately realized world stands as a towering achievement in the fantasy genre, distinguishing the Malazan series in a league of its own.

Gardens of the Moon Writing Style Review

Steven Erikson's writing style in "Gardens of the Moon" is distinctive and ambitious, with a clear focus on complex narrative structures and intricate detailing. The prose, often described as dense, is lush with intricate details and layers of meaning, requiring the readers to fully engage with the text.

Erikson's style leans toward the poetic, enhancing the mythical and epic feel of the story. His descriptions are vivid and imaginative, painting an enthralling picture of his complex world and its inhabitants. The dialogue can be philosophical at times, revealing Erikson's knack for probing the deeper, darker aspects of human nature and existence.

The storytelling is not linear, often employing flashbacks and varying perspectives. This non-linear style contributes to the complexity of the plot and character development, building intrigue and providing deep insights into the characters' motivations and histories. Erikson doesn't hold the reader's hand but instead demands their full engagement, encouraging them to piece together the vast puzzle that is the Malazan world.

While this intricate and sophisticated writing style undoubtedly adds depth and richness to the narrative, it can also prove challenging for some readers. Erikson doesn't shy away from using elaborate and sophisticated vocabulary, which, while enriching the narrative style, may require occasional recourse to a dictionary.

Given the intricate complexity, lush descriptions, and the intellectual challenge it offers, I would rate Erikson's writing style a 4.5 out of 5. While it might seem daunting to some, others will find it a rewarding experience that enhances the rich tapestry of the narrative and the intricate world-building of the Malazan series. In the realm of fantasy literature, Erikson's dense, elaborate prose is a unique, standout feature that sets him apart.

Gardens of the Moon Originality Review

"Gardens of the Moon," the opening salvo in Steven Erikson's ambitious Malazan Book of the Fallen series, brims with originality. It introduces readers to a world that defies conventional fantasy tropes and breathes new life into the genre.

What sets Erikson's work apart is his approach to storytelling and world-building. He doesn't spoon-feed his readers; instead, he throws them into the deep end of a vast, complex world and invites them to swim. This approach, while demanding, allows readers to feel a sense of discovery and achievement as they gradually decipher the world's intricacies.

The concept of a high fantasy world rooted in anthropological and archaeological realism is relatively unique in the genre. Erikson, an anthropologist and archaeologist, uses his professional background to create a world that feels lived-in, with deep historical roots and cultures that have evolved over millennia. This lends an impressive depth and realism to the Malazan world.

The intricate and intersecting plotlines, sprawling character cast, and the blend of high fantasy with elements of grimdark make "Gardens of the Moon" stand out from typical fantasy narratives. Furthermore, Erikson's exploration of themes such as imperialism, power, and the nature of gods and ascendants offers a fresh take on these age-old concepts.

However, Erikson's refusal to hold the reader's hand, though innovative, may not appeal to everyone. The initial learning curve can be steep, and the non-linear storytelling, while original, may be disorienting for some readers.

Given these factors, I would rate "Gardens of the Moon" a 4.7 out of 5 for originality. Erikson's innovative approach to world-building, storytelling, and thematic exploration makes this book a standout entry in the fantasy genre. Despite potential hurdles for some readers, the originality that Erikson brings to the table is well worth the effort.

Overall Conclusion on Gardens of the Moon and Position Across All Fantasy Novels

In the grand tapestry of fantasy literature, "Gardens of the Moon" unquestionably stands as a titan, embodying a sublime mix of complexity, originality, and expansive world-building that few can rival. It is a vanguard for high fantasy, leaving an indelible mark that extends beyond its immediate narrative and continues to reverberate across the fantasy genre.

The book, and the series as a whole, represents a significant departure from traditional fantasy norms. Erikson's style is deeply philosophical, characterized by a fierce refusal to handhold the reader. This approach has created an immersive, richly complex world that respects the reader's intelligence and promises substantial rewards for those willing to journey through its labyrinthine intricacies. The Malazan world is not simply a backdrop; it is a living, breathing entity that is as much a character in the book as any of the myriad individuals that populate its pages.

While the sheer scale and complexity of "Gardens of the Moon" may present an initial hurdle to some, it is this very depth that distinguishes the book. The plethora of characters, cultures, races, magic systems, religions, and histories coalesce to form a landscape of staggering intricacy, challenging conventions of storytelling and world-building. This abundance of depth and detail, combined with Erikson's raw, unflinching narrative, makes the book an utterly absorbing read.

It is important to mention the character development. Erikson expertly navigates an array of characters, giving each their distinct voice and path. Characters are not simply pawns on a chessboard, but fully-realized beings, each with their own motivations, fears, and hopes. It's this commitment to character development that injects the narrative with emotional weight, ensuring the events resonate on a deeper level.

Moreover, the book thrives on ambiguity, eschewing clear-cut morality and challenging readers to grapple with difficult questions. This moral complexity permeates every aspect of the narrative, from the multifaceted characters to the broader themes explored.

In terms of originality, "Gardens of the Moon" is a beacon. It's a bold exploration of what fantasy can be, unafraid to shatter norms and push boundaries. It's the beginning of a groundbreaking series that continues to inspire and influence the genre.

On the whole, "Gardens of the Moon" has more than earned its place among the pantheon of fantasy literature. It may not cater to every reader's tastes, and indeed, its demanding nature may initially deter some. Yet, for those who embrace its complexity, it promises a journey that is as challenging as it is rewarding, a journey that reshapes perceptions of what fantasy can be.

This 4.54 rating is a testament to the remarkable ambition and accomplishment that "Gardens of the Moon" represents. It is not just a book; it's an experience, a world to get lost in, and a standard-bearer for immersive, boundary-pushing fantasy. For all these reasons, it remains a touchstone of the genre and a must-read for any serious fantasy enthusiast. Pride and Prophecy keeps an updated rating of all fantasy novels across planes of existence. This will only be sortable on desktop viewing.